Why would

It only takes a minute to sign up. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I don't understand. Why would you do that? And by convention the present tense is used for reasoning in general, so it might be applied to the past.

Why would have you done that? People are not always this deliberate. But not only does the second question ask after the past, the change in word order subtly reorients the interrogator in terms of skepticism.

Consider the difference:. In the first case, I can probably keep telling her ridiculous nonsense. In the second case, the jig is probably up and it's time to find something more interesting to do. It is hypothetical, it hasn't happened. It is spoken in the present about something that has not occurred. This sentence asks why B would do something, and sort implies that B would do it again, as though it were a part of who he is.

At the time of the analysis, students could receive one of two diplomas: a basic one and an advanced one. All that aside, the research lends credence to the criticism of standardized testing as a flawed measurement of student achievement. Skip to content Site Navigation The Atlantic. Popular Latest. The Atlantic Crossword. Sign In Subscribe. Math Is Personal Jessica Nordell. Thomas S. Dee, Will Dobbie, Brian A.

Viewed 50k times. Improve this question. JavaLatte Mert Ileri Mert Ileri 25 1 1 gold badge 2 2 silver badges 6 6 bronze badges. Asking for either willingness or necessity. Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. Person B: Why would I steal a penny? Person A: Well There's no reason for that. Person B: Why should I steal a penny? And his father recently criticized the Browns on social media.

So for the Browns, Beckham was no longer worth the trouble, and they decided to cut ties. In his first three seasons combined, he had 4, yards and 35 touchdowns — with at least 10 touchdowns and 1, yards in each season. In the four-plus seasons since then, Beckham has 2, yards and 16 touchdowns in 45 games. He played 43 games during his first three seasons. He also eclipsed 1, yards in 1, , but he did very little in and , due to injuries — and yards.

Beckham this season has just 17 catches in six games, for yards and zero touchdowns.